Metal Siding vs Fiber Cement Siding

Many homeowners find themselves struggling to choose between metal vs cement siding for their homes. The differences between metal siding and cement siding begin with installation. Fiber cement siding requires special tools to cut the material, releasing toxic silica dust.

Other issues to weigh between metal siding and fiber cement siding are the amount of painting and caulking required and each material’s resistance to water damage. Cement siding is a heavy and durable material but with limitations.

We’ve provided the chart below to help you make comparing metal and fiber-cement siding easy. We’d love to speak with you if you have questions after reviewing.

Feature EDCO Metal Siding Fiber Cement Siding
  • Does not absorb water
  • Will not swell, decompose or develop mold over time
  • Not waterproof
  • Contains high moisture content when manufactured. Shrinkage will happen over time, leaving gaps between panels
  • If not installed properly, gap clearances can create serious moisture concerns
  • Realistic wood grain look
  • Mimics real wood siding
  • Lifetime non-prorated limited warranty that is transferrable
  • Includes material and labor
  • 30-year limited warranty when installed properly
  • Factory finish comes with a 15-year warranty against flaking or fading
Fire Resistance
  • Not susceptible to deformation from exposure to heat sources
  • Non-combustible
  • Composed of 90% sand, which makes it fire-resistant but not fireproof
  • Little to no caulking is required
  • Overlapping of siding panels allows for expansion and contraction due to temperature changes
  • No nailheads are exposed
  • Recaulking might be needed every few years
  • Proper respiration is required when cutting fiber cement as it generates silica dust, which is toxic to breathe
  • Cut ends need to be painted
  • Manufactured with at least 25% recycled steel
  • 100% recyclable
  • It is not recyclable
  • Approx. 100 lbs per 100 sq. feet
  • Approx. 300 lbs per 100 sq. feet
  • Easily acclimates to any weather condition and will not chip, crack or peel
  • Rigid and can crack or chip
Hail and Fade Protection
  • 35-year fade warranty
  • 50-year hail protection
  • Factory finish comes with a 15-year warranty against flaking or fading
  • Little to no maintenance is required
  • Requires periodic painting

Durability and Maintenance

When considering siding materials, durability is a top concern. EDCO metal siding excels in various weather conditions without chipping, cracking, or peeling. Its maintenance is straightforward, often requiring nothing more than occasional cleaning. Fiber cement siding, while sturdy, requires periodic painting to maintain its appearance and integrity over the years.

Aesthetic Appeal and Installation Insights

Both siding types offer distinct aesthetic appeals. EDCO's metal siding provides a modern look with its clean lines and vibrant colors, whereas fiber cement brings a classic touch. Metal siding installation is quicker, while fiber cement installation is more labor-intensive, considering its weight and the precautions needed when cutting.

Environmental Impact and Cost Efficiency

Sustainability-minded homeowners might lean towards EDCO metal siding for its recyclable properties and use of recycled materials. While fiber cement is not recyclable, its durability contributes to a long lifespan, potentially reducing waste — but that lifespan is typically much less than steel siding. Initial costs and long-term investments also play a part in the decision. Metal siding and fiber cement siding tend to have roughly the same upfront cost, but metal siding requires less time and expense to maintain, offering savings over time.

Consistency with Metal Roofing

Pairing metal siding with metal roofing can create a cohesive and visually appealing exterior for your home. If you opt for EDCO metal siding, extending metal to your roofing can enhance the overall durability and sustainability of your home's exterior, providing consistent protection against the elements. This combination not only offers a unified look but also capitalizes on metal's low maintenance and longevity benefits. Moreover, the wide range of colors and finishes in metal roofing allows for seamless integration with metal and engineered wood siding, ensuring your home stands out for its elegance and resilience.

Choosing the Right Siding For Your Project

Selecting between EDCO metal siding and fiber cement siding hinges on balancing various factors, from aesthetic desires and durability needs to environmental considerations and budget constraints. By thoroughly evaluating each material's pros and cons, homeowners can choose the siding that not only elevates the beauty of their home but also enhances its value and standing for years to come.

In the quest for the perfect siding, consider how each option aligns with your project requirements, budget, maintenance needs, and environmental impact, ensuring a choice you'll be satisfied with for many years.